Tuesday, July 15, 2008

The Shock Doctrine and it's Continued Implementation

Journalist Naomi Klein came out with her novel "The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism" in September of 2007. In this book Klein labels "The Shock Doctrine" as what happens when populations go through a collective shock--wars, floods, an economic crisis--and in the immediate aftermath, governments push through public policies that would otherwise be unpopular. Examples that she outlines in the book range from Pinochet's coup in 1973 to the closing of public housing and public schooling after Hurricane Katrina, to the massive privatization of the so-call "War on Terror". The implementation of the "Shock Doctrine" traces its roots back to the belief by economists like Milton Friedman who believed that "Only a crisis real or perceived, produces real change."

It is this belief that forms the historical context for the "Shock doctrine" as well as the idea that when such "opportunities" arise in the form of natural disasters or wars, it is the ideas and policies that are lying around that can be implemented in the immediate aftermath. Also relevant to the discussion of the "Shock Doctrine" is the longstanding belief that the global market has triumphed democratically. Instead, it is shown in the book how the expansion of the global market has often been a violent and un-democratic process in order to push through policies that would otherwise be rejected by the public.

Given this brief background to the basic concept of the "Shock Doctrine" I will move on to a recent interview that Naomi Klein gave on Decomcracy Now! Klein begins with discussion of how the "shock doctrine" has become much more relevant even in the last 10 months since her book originally came out. She makes the current oil crisis into a prime example for what she discusses in the book. Klein states:


There is a clear political strategy, and has been for several decades, to exploit these moments when people are desperate for quick-fix solutions and more inclined to believe in a kind of a magical cure, to push through very, very unpopular policies that don’t actually solve the crisis at hand, that don’t actually help people, but are incredibly profitable for multinational corporations.

Klein goes on to apply this to the current oil crisis and with President Bush lifting the Federal Ban on Offshore Drilling. She states that President Bush is "holding the country at ransom" by failing to address any long-term solution to our dependence on oil and by demanding that Congress pass a law to allow oil companies to drill off the American coast. Klein states that the President is "selling a myth" because most experts agree that oil would not flow from newly established rigs for another 7-10 years and would not cause any significant change in our current oil prices. Many of the proponents of offshore drilling as well as drilling in ANWR claim that just the announcement of drilling for more oil will drive prices down, but in addition to the realization that after Bush's announcement, the price of oil went up, Klein states:


There’s a speculative bubble going on right now, and this market is being played. I mean, I think this is really the new bubble. Actually, it’s replacing the housing bubble. And, you know, any time anything bad happens in the world, that’s the indication for speculators to drive the price up. It happened yesterday. Bush announced that he would be opening up to offshore oil drilling, but at the same time, there was an oil strike in Brazil, so the price of oil went up. So everything drives the price of oil up. I think it’s really a classic bubble. Certainly, there are some supply issues, but I actually don’t think that that is the main reason why the price of oil is going up.


Implementation of policies that are often unpopular among the population, but preferential to corporate interests during times of distress and crisis; we are seeing the Shock Doctrine in its current form and it is essential that the public realizes they are being "shocked" and push back against the massive media campaign that is being rolled out by the big oil and gas companies.

3 comments:

Myrisa said...

just discovered your blog, will include it in our blogroll in paisciego.blogspot.com

The Commentator said...

Klein has it backwards.

Chris Johnson said...

the commenator:

I would be interested to hear an elaboration on your comment.